L | 1874-01-17 | Clapham Rovers | 2-1 | Sheffield FC | QF | ||||
W | 1873-11-22 | Sheffield FC | 1-0 | Pilgrims FC | 2R | ||||
D | 1873-11-17 | Shropshire Wanderers FC | 0-0 | Sheffield FC | 1R | ||||
D | 1873-10-30 | Sheffield FC | 0-0 | Shropshire Wanderers FC | 1R |
L | 1873-11-22 | Sheffield FC | 1-0 | Pilgrims FC | 2R | ||||
W | 1873-10-09 | Pilgrims FC | 1-0 | Marlow FC | 1R |